Are you finding time to post Instagram Stories daily?
If not, you’re leaving engagement on the table.
For most people, the problem is that manually posting Instagram Stories every day is a slog.
But here’s the thing: Stories are one of the BEST ways to stay top-of-mind with your audience.
They keep your brand visible, drive engagement, and give you a direct line to your followers.
The solution? Use a tool like Post Planner to schedule Instagram Stories in advance, automate posting, and recycle what works.
In this article, I’ll walk you through exactly how to do it (and give you some proven tips to boost engagement and save hours every week).
Let’s get started!
I'll cover:
- How to Schedule Instagram Stories to Save Time and Increase Engagement
- Strategies to improve Instagram Story engagement
- Conclusion
How to use Post Planner to schedule Instagram Stories
If you’re manually posting Instagram Stories every day, I’ve got news for you:
You’re doing it the hard way.
Stories are one of the best tools for staying top-of-mind, but they’re also the easiest to forget (or ignore) when things get busy.
The result?
You’re missing valuable opportunities to engage your audience and grow your brand.
That’s where Post Planner comes in.
Instead of scrambling to post at the right time, you can queue up a batch of Instagram Stories in advance and let Post Planner take care of the publishing.
Below, I’ll walk you through exactly how to do it: from planning your Story strategy to sourcing (or creating) content, scheduling it, and analyzing what works.
Step 1: Create an Instagram posting schedule
Before you post anything, you need a game plan.
An automated Instagram Story schedule ensures you show up consistently. And consistency is what trains your audience to pay attention (and the algorithm to favor you).
In other words, the more consistently you post Stories, the more likely your followers will see them and the more chances you have to build trust, spark conversations, and drive action.
Inside Post Planner, you can create a recurring posting schedule for Instagram Stories using the “Posting Plan” feature.
Here’s how:
- Create a Bucket for Instagram Stories.
- Select your desired days and times in your Posting Plan. Have them draw from your Stories Bucket.
- Assign your Story content to those time slots (we’ll discuss how to do this in the following steps).
If you want, you can get more granular in your Buckets. For example, you could have a “Funny Stories” Bucket that you draw from on Mondays, a “Educational Stories” Bucket that you draw from on Fridays, etc.
Pro tip: Start with 3–5 weekly Stories and build from there. Aim for a mix of education, engagement, and entertainment.
Step 2 (option 1): Source a high-quality video or image
You don’t always need to create content from scratch.
You just need to know where to look.
Post Planner makes it easy to source high-quality images and videos for your Instagram Stories.
You can search for viral content, trending posts, and media by keyword in the Content tab. Whether you want motivational quotes, funny memes, niche videos, or customer success stories, you’ll find content already proven to perform.
You can filter the results by content type (such as video or images for your Stories) to help you find your ideal content even quicker.
Once you’ve found something you like, add it to your queue by clicking the green + symbol over each piece of content you want to schedule (you can schedule multiple stories simultaneously by selecting multiple pieces of content).
Pro tip: Look for highly visual content that matches your page’s voice and your audience’s goals. You can customize it to fit your exact needs, but it always helps to start with a great base.
Step 2 (option 2): Create a high-quality video or image
Your feed should NEVER become just rehashed content from other creators. You should always mix in a blend of curated and owned content to keep your feed fresh, original, and on-brand.
Post Planner’s built-in Content Studio lets you easily design Story-ready visuals — even if you’re not a designer.
Start by uploading your media, pulling from the built-in stock library, or using a tool like DALL-E to generate custom AI images from a prompt. Then hop into the Content Studio to crop for a 9:16 aspect ratio (ideal for Instagram Stories), add text, stickers, filters, or your logo.
Once your design is ready, you can save it to your library to use in future scheduled posts or drop it straight into a post immediately.
Pro tip: Use DALL-E to create background images that match your brand aesthetic. Just describe the vibe or setting you want (“cozy café in the morning” or “sunset over a mountain trail”), then edit and overlay your message in Post Planner’s Content Studio.
Step 3: Customize your post
Now it’s time to make your Story post your own.
Once you’ve chosen or created your image or video, Post Planner’s Post Composer lets you fine-tune it for Instagram.
Here’s how to do it:
- Choose which Bucket you want your post/s in at the top of the Post Composer.
- Select “Story” under Instagram settings in the Post Composer.
- Add a caption and a first comment if desired.
- Decide if the post should be recycled later, or if it’s a one-time drop.
If you’re having trouble coming up with an engaging caption or high-value hashtags, use the AI feature at the top of the Post Composer to help you come up with them in seconds!
Pro tip: Keep your Story captions short and punchy. Most people will only glance for a second or two, so make those words count. Use emojis, clear CTAs, or questions to grab attention fast.
Step 4: Schedule your post
With your Story ready, it’s time to put it on autopilot.
In Post Planner, you can schedule your Instagram Story to publish at the perfect time without needing to log in or get a mobile reminder.
At the bottom of the Post Composer, select one of the options:
- “Add to queue” puts the post in the selected Bucket, where it'll post at the next available time slot allocated to that Bucket.
- “Share Next” drops the post into the next available posting time slot.
- “Share Now” posts the Story immediately.
- “Schedule Post” lets you select the exact date/time you want to make your post, even if you don’t have a slot in your posting plan.
Post Planner handles the rest and ensures it goes out exactly when you want.
Pro tip: Use past analytics or Instagram Insights to find when your followers are most active, and time your posts to match (more on this below!).
Step 5: Analyze and recycle
Once your Instagram Story goes live, don’t just forget about it.
Learn from it!
Post Planner’s History tab helps you track how your Stories are performing. This takes the guesswork out of your content strategy and enables you to double down on what works.
When you find a Story that performs well, re-queue it with just a couple of clicks. You can recycle evergreen content on a custom schedule, so your best work keeps delivering results without extra effort.
Pro tip: Don’t recycle every Story. Focus on posts that drive engagement or conversions, and space them out to avoid repetition fatigue with your audience.
6 Strategies to improve Instagram Story engagement
Creating Instagram Stories is only half the battle. You need to optimize for engagement if you want real results — more views, replies, shares, and clicks.
The good news?
Minor tweaks to your strategy can lead to significant improvements.
In this section, I’ll cover 6 proven tactics to help your Stories get seen, spark interaction, and drive meaningful actions from your audience.
These strategies work whether you’re a solopreneur, agency, or content creator — and they’re easy to implement starting today.
1. Interact with your followers
Instagram Stories aren’t just for broadcasting — they’re for building relationships.
When you use interactive features like polls, quizzes, emoji sliders, and question boxes, you invite your audience to participate instead of just watching. That 2-way engagement boosts your visibility in the algorithm and makes followers more likely to stick around for future content.
Try using Stories to ask questions, get feedback, or even crowdsource ideas.
Most importantly, don’t forget to RESPOND when people engage—every reply is a chance to deepen the connection.
Pro tip: Use a question box to ask, “What do you want to see more of on this page?” Then turn those answers into future content.
Boom. Engagement and research in one move.
2. Cross-post your content
Tired of coming up with a new piece of content for Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, etc?
You don’t need to reinvent the wheel for every platform.
Cross-posting your Instagram Stories to Facebook and other social channels (or turning them into feed posts and Reels) helps you reach a wider audience without creating new content from scratch. It also reinforces your message across different channels, which builds familiarity and trust with your followers.
Post Planner makes cross-posting simple.
When creating a Story, select the other platforms where you want to publish at the top of the Composer.
Then, customize the post for each channel where you’ll post the content in the lower portion of the Composer. That way, your content feels native everywhere it appears.
Pro tip: When cross-posting a Story to your feed, tweak the caption slightly to match the tone of that format. What works as a quick visual on Stories might need more context in a feed post.
3. Identify the best posting times
Because the algorithm prioritizes more recent Instagram Stories, timing is EVERYTHING to maximize your viewer count.
If you post when your audience is most active, your Stories are more likely to show up first in their feed.
Post when they’re not active? Even your best content can get buried before anyone sees it.
Use Post Planner’s analytics to find the days and times your followers are most engaged.
Then, schedule your Stories to go live during those windows. Over time, you’ll start to notice patterns, and you can keep optimizing based on what the data tells you.
Pro tip: Start by testing posts during lunch (11 am–1 pm) and evenings (6 pm–9 pm), when most people are scrolling. Then dial in your timing based on actual engagement results.
4. Post frequently
If you only post Stories occasionally, you’re missing EASY wins.
The golden rule of Instagram: Consistency is key!
The more often you post, the more chances you have to appear at the top of your followers’ feeds (and stay top-of-mind). But keeping up with daily Stories can feel overwhelming if you start from scratch each time.
That’s where Post Planner’s Content Streams come into play. These streams pull top-performing content from your niche, so you always have something relevant to share.
Even if you don’t share content you find on the Streams directly, these high-performing pieces of content you find can serve as excellent sources of inspiration for your content.
You can quickly turn the content you find (or create) into Story posts on Post Planner, fill your queue, and keep your posting schedule full without burning out.
Pro tip: Aim for at least one Story per day. If that feels like too much, batch your content once a week and let Post Planner handle the rest.
5. Vary your content
If every Story looks and sounds the same, your audience will skip.
Mixing up your content keeps people interested and coming back for more.
Try alternating between various types of content:
- Behind-the-scenes clips
- Educational tips
- Customer testimonials
- Product sneak peeks
- Polls
- Quick videos
This variety keeps your feed fresh and appeals to different audience segments.
With Post Planner, it’s easy to organize content types into content Buckets (like “Tips,” “Testimonials,” or “Promos”) and rotate them automatically. By organizing your content into different Buckets, you can have your posting plan draw from different Buckets on different days (as shown below).
The result? Your Stories stay consistent and diverse without extra effort.
Pro tip: Use a simple formula like: teach something on Monday, share a customer quote on Wednesday, and post a fun poll on Friday. Systems beat guesswork EVERY time.
6. Use Stories with strong CTAs
Don't expect results if your Stories don’t tell people what to do next.
A clear, direct call-to-action (CTA) gives your viewers a reason to swipe, tap, reply, or click.
Whether promoting a product, collecting feedback, or driving engagement, your CTA should spell out PRECISELY what you want them to do.
Try CTAs like “Swipe up to shop,” “Reply with your favorite,” or use interactive features like polls.
Pro tip: Mix up your CTAs so your content doesn’t feel repetitive. If you only ever ask your followers to click a link, they’re less likely to keep engaging. Try some CTAs listed above or use AI to generate CTA ideas for your post!
Ready to start saving HOURS every week?
Instagram Stories are one of the fastest ways to build real engagement, but only if you show up consistently and strategically.
By using Post Planner to schedule, customize, and recycle your Stories, you’ll save hours every week while keeping your audience hooked.
Not a Post Planner user yet? Sign up for an account to automate your Instagram posting completely FREE here.
No Comments